Google’s announcement of Google TV promises to revolutionize the level of interaction between your television and the Internet, but the concept itself is not new. Many devices already have varying levels of Internet connectivity and service.
Two of the largest TV and Blu-ray Disc player (BDP) manufacturers, Sony and Samsung, both offer Internet services through many of their TVs and BDPs. From music and video streaming to social networking, their offerings continue to grow. But which one is better? We will look at the user interfaces, the services and applications offered, and the types of devices available, all in an effort to help you make a better informed decision for your next purchase.
Interface
Both manufacturers give the user full control over their interfaces using the supplied remotes.
Sony has a pretty standard interface across most of its devices. The interface that you find on the Playstation 3 and PSP is the same one used for Sony TVs and BDPs. It is intentionally plain and bi-directional. If you like that, you will not be disappointed with any of Sony’s products. If you do not like it, you are pretty much stuck. What it lacks in style, it makes up for in usability and simplicity.
Sony’s Internet TV is available for most Bravia devices, Internet-ready TVs and Blu-ray Disc players.
Samsung’s interface is more vivid, providing shiny buttons for each app and the ability to add or remove apps from the Samsung App Store, all built into the interface. You can also add and arrange favorite apps. It still manages to keep some of the simplicity of Sony’s interface, while also adding some nice visuals.
Samsung’s Internet@TV is available for newer LCD and LED TVs, as well as many Blu-ray Disc players.
Services
Sony currently offers about 30 Internet content providers, including audio content like Pandora, Slacker, and NPR, as well as video content like Netflix, Amazon On Demand, and YouTube. It is expected to add Hulu Plus in Fall of 2010, and Google TV will be added at some point in the future, although this may only be for new devices.
[youtube yRsMszkMxG0 500 375]
In addition, Sony TVs have widgets for Facebook, Twitter, Yahoo, and TV Guide. Sony also provides potentially game-breaking content in the form of Internet video podcasts, such as some of the G4 and Revision 3 shows. Unfortunately, they do not keep the feeds updated and do not allow users to change them. The feeds that still work, however, are useful but make it an inferior feature when compared to software like Boxee.
Sony does, however, provide a “play from computer” service for Internet-ready TVs only (not Blu-ray players), which requires Windows and certain video formats. This could make it easier to download online content and stream it to the television.
[youtube 18yAFjItu4Y 500 375]
Samsung currently showcases around 30 content providers, such as Blockbuster, Amazon, Netflix, Hulu Plus, YouTube, Cinemanow, Facebook, Skype, Google Maps, and a host of games.
One of the impressive additional features of Samsung is the App store, which will offer additional apps that users can add to their TVs. While Samsung has more options, it lacks some of the diversity of content that Sony has added.
Sony Internet TV | Samsung Internet@TV |
Amazon Video | Accu Weather |
Blip.tv | Amazon Video |
Concierge.com | AP News |
Crackle | Blockbuster |
Dailymotion | Catch it |
eHow | Cinemanow |
epicurious | Dailymotion |
Dalphy Trial | |
Fear Net | Draculas Coffin |
FORD Models | Dynamic Bowling |
Framechannel | |
Golf link.com | Getty Images |
Howcast | Google Maps |
Livestrong | Hulu Plus |
myplay | Kurakku |
Netflix | Magic Cube Trial |
NPR | Mahjong Fruits |
On Networks | Memory |
Pandora | Minigame Pack T |
PlayJam | MiniMiniCook |
Podcasts | Netflix |
Qriocity | Pandora |
Singing Fool | Picassa |
Slacker | Quizmaster |
Style.com | Rockswap |
TV Guide | Rovi guide |
SPS TV | |
USA Today Sports | Sudoku |
video detective | Survival Bakery TriaSudoku+ Trial |
Videocast.com | Tcrew Trial |
Wired | Texas Holdem |
Yahoo Finance | |
Yahoo music | USA Today |
Yahoo News, Weather, and Sports | Vudu |
YouTube | Wisestar |
Hulu Plus (Fall 2010) | YouTube |
With both manufacturers, the availability of services depends on the devices. For example, many of the widgets are only available on the TVs and not on the BDPs. Additionally, some services, like Amazon On Demand, Hulu Plus, and Netflix are available only at additional cost. Both are also adding 3D support for 3D-ready televisions.
The Winner
Both manufacturers have built in a nice system that allows them to update their services over the Internet. This means that competition can be easily matched, if the companies are willing to keep their services updated and constantly evolving, as that is the nature of the Internet.
Samsung’s interface is more attractive, but Sony’s is simpler. Your choice will ultimately depend on preference. The ability to add apps and mark favorites, however, pushes Samsung ahead of Sony.
They are about even in terms of the quantity of content providers. Samsung has a slight edge here with apps like Blockbuster, Vudu, and Hulu Plus, all with streaming HD video content. Sony would have a clear advantage with their video podcasts, if they decided to pay them any attention and keep them updated. The “play from computer” capability is a definite plus, although they need to expand their supported formats and platforms.
Finally, the Samsung app store looks promising, and if it gets the kind of attention Samsung is hoping for, they will be the clear winners. Neither service allows true customization that you would get with an HTPC and media software like Boxee or XBMC. That means that true integration of your TV with the Internet will still likely require a computer.
Tags: Google TV, Internet TV, Samsung, Sony
Discussion 2 Comments